love-and-desire-discussion-post-5

Why do you think Catherine chooses Edgar even though she believes Heathcliff to be part of her own soul?

What do you think of her decision?

initial Post: 100 words minimum

Prof Bishton’s Intro to Discussion: Though the question/prompt naturally gives rise to many opinions, after sharing analysis, bring those opinions back to consideration of literary merit.

Specifically:

How do you find the decision affecting the story line?

How would the tale play out differently if the decision was different?

Would it be as satisfying?